Inside Look

Great Lakes Center's exclusive subscriber email featuring key points, information and social media content about reviews and research
June 11, 2020READ IN BROWSER
Hello, Great Lakes Center subscriber:

A new report published by the Reason Foundation provides information about school funding inequities in Arizona, but lacks necessary analysis to make its funding recommendations useful. The Reason Foundation explains Arizona’s complicated school finance formula, pointing out its many inequities, then provides 16 policy recommendations to change the state’s school funding system.

However, a new Think Twice review by the National Education Policy Center found the report fails to critically consider its own recommendations. Read on to learn more.

Dr. Gretchen Dziadosz
Executive Director
Great Lakes Center for Education Research and Practice

REPORT REVIEWED

Think Twice Reviewer David R. Garcia, a professor at Arizona State University, reviewed A Roadmap to Fix Arizona School Finance: Steering the Grand Canyon State Toward Fairness and Innovation in K-12 Education. The report points out funding inequities and makes policy recommendations to change the funding system in Arizona’s schools.

WHAT THE REVIEWERS FOUND

Garcia found the report lacks supporting evidence to make its many policy recommendations useful. The report describes how Arizona’s lowest-income school districts receive less funding from state and local sources than higher-income school districts. As in many states, Arizona’s school districts with lower property wealth have higher tax rates and generate less revenue than higher property wealth school districts.

The report makes 16 complex policy recommendations its author argues will improve the “transparency, equity and effectiveness of Arizona’s school finance system.” The recommendations would equate to a complete overhaul of Arizona’s school funding method.

While the report points out existing inequities, it does not provide any assessment of the impact of any of its recommendations on Arizona’s schools. In his review, Garcia calculates the impact of two of the report’s policy recommendations, demonstrating how they would decrease the state’s already meager per-pupil expenditures.

The report also shows a lack of coordination among its recommendations, which may encourage legislators to cherry pick which recommendations to implement. This would lend itself to a piecemeal approach that created Arizona’s inequitable school funding formula in the first place, Garcia concluded.

Overall, the report is not a credible policy document because it doesn’t assess the impact of any of its recommendations. It is also undermined by the lack of coordination among its numerous policy recommendations.

Read the full review on the Great Lakes Center website or on the National Education Policy Center website.
Read the review →

WHY YOU SHOULD CARE

The Reason Foundation’s report advocates for policies that are not well substantiated or coordinated, which could lead to legislators cherry picking which recommendations to implement. This lack of coordination mirrors how Arizona’s inequitable school finance formula was created. As a result, the recommendations could lead to further inequities in school funding.

TALKING POINTS TO REMEMBER

  1. A new report by the Reason Foundation lacks necessary evidence to make useful policy recommendations for Arizona’s school funding method.
     
  2. The review found the report does not assess the impact of any of its recommendations, making them useless to Arizona’s policymakers.
     
  3. Implementation of the recommended policies could lead to further inequities in Arizona’s school funding approach.

SOCIAL SHARES

Want to share this Think Twice Review with your social networks? We drafted some sample social media posts for your use.
A new report published by the Reason Foundation advocates for reforms to Arizona’s school funding method without analyzing their impact. A new report published by the Reason Foundation advocates for reforms to Arizona’s school funding method without analyzing their impact.
A new review by @NEPCtweet found a Reason Foundation report fails to make useful recommendations for changing Arizona’s school funding formula. A new review by @NEPCtweet found a Reason Foundation report fails to make useful recommendations for changing Arizona’s school funding formula.
A new review by @NEPCtweet found a Reason Foundation report lacks analysis on the impact of its recommended school funding reforms in Arizona. A new review by @NEPCtweet found a Reason Foundation report lacks analysis on the impact of its recommended school funding reforms in Arizona.
Follow Us
Facebook
Twitter
Think Twice, a project of the National Education Policy Center, provides the public, policymakers and the press with timely, academically sound reviews of selected publications. The project is made possible by funding from the Great Lakes Center for Education Research and Practice.
Copyright © 2019 Great Lakes Center for Education Research & Practice, All rights reserved. 
You are receiving this email because you opted in via our website. 

Our mailing address is:
Great Lakes Center for Education Research & Practice
PO Box 1263
East Lansing, MI 48826-1263

Add us to your address book

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.